SAVE LONGSTONE EDGE

SAVE LONGSTONE EDGE

How You Can Help: Write a Letter

Write a Letter to your MP

At the present time this is the most important thing you can do, since the only way the quarrying is likely to be stopped is through Government action. Write to your MP:

Dear (your MP)
As one of your constituents and as a visitor to the Peak District National Park I am shocked to discover that national park status is not preventing Longstone Edge being destroyed by extensive quarrying. Could you please ask Hilary Benn at DEFRA to intervene urgently to find a permanent solution.

A letter making similar points but in your own words would be even better. Now please send it to your MP (you can find your MP here):
   The House of Commons
   London SW1A 0AA
Your MP should forward the letter to the Minister, and send you a copy of the Minister's reply. It is very encouraging to know that a Minister must reply to every letter he or she receives from an MP - and that more than 8 letters on a subject is considered 'significant'.

More Letters to Write

When you have written to your MP - keep writing!

One of the key purposes of what we are trying to do is to raise awareness of the campaign on a national level. The Government, through DEFRA the funding agency of the National Parks, says that it's a local issue, yet the park is a 'National Park' with 'central' funding. DEFRA claims that the PDNPA has all the powers it needs to revoke the permission if it doesn't like it, but the problem is that it doesn't have the money to do it because it would have to compensate the landowner.

This is a perfect case where well-written letters, covering range of subjects, are sent by many supporters to targeted politicians and officials. It is very encouraging to know that a minister of state must reply to every letter he/she receives - and that more than 8 letters on a subject is
considered 'significant'.

To get you started, we have highlighted a number of key issues/failures of government, provided lists of people to write to, and also suggested different angles to write from.

In addition, apart from writing yourself as a concerned local resident you might ask friends and family from further afield, who may visit you from time to time, to write from their perspective.

KEY ISSUES

A: National Parks - for the conservation and enhancement of the countryside

  1. Quarrying should not be allowed to take place in areas of outstanding natural beauty, such as National Parks, unless it is to meet a proven national need for and the materials being quarried are unavailable elsewhere. There is no national shortage of limestone.
  2. National Parks should have sufficient powers in law and appropriate funding to be able to revise or revoke old mineral permissions where they conflict with their modern day obligations 'to conserve and enhance the natural beauty, wildlife and cultural heritage of the area'.
  3. Closing the ridiculous loophole in the 1995 Environment Act, whereby a Minerals Planning Authority (in this case the PDNPA) can't revise an old permission without evaluating an 'Environmental Impact Assessment' which must be provided by the quarry operator, but there is no compulsion or sanction on the operator to provide one!
  4. The National Parks are funded by DEFRA (on a declining budget) but DEFRA has nothing to do with 'Planning Matters', which are covered by DCLG (formerly ODPM), which isn't interested in providing funds to National Parks because that is DEFRA's domain. This is something of a Catch 22 situation.
  5. Bizarrely, the Peak District would probably be better served on this matter if it weren't in a 'National' Park! It would be governed by Derbyshire County Council, which is (at least) democratically elected (which means that public opinion can change policy) and also has its own fund-raising powers (and a much larger budget) so they could probably deal with this if they so wished.
  6. The intellectual laziness that allows Limestone to be classified as a 'mineral' in UK planning law - even though it is nowhere defined as such.
  7. Why can't the Aggregates Levy Sustainability Fund be used to solve this problem?  After all, this was (supposed to be) the primary justification for collecting the levy.  See link: http://www.defra.gov.uk/environment/waste/aggregates/delivery.htm#2

B: Aggregates Levy

Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs have been (apparently) scandalously negligent in not collecting Aggregates Levy on the Limestone Aggregate removed from Backdale - @£1.60 per tonne, and 20,000 tonnes per month, how can they allow this situation of owing over £1.6m to persist.  It is quite shocking for them to hide behind the outcome of the planning appeal/inquiry.

Objective of Levy

To address, by taxation, the environmental costs associated with quarrying operations (noise, dust, visual intrusion, loss of amenity and damage to biodiversity) in line with the Government's statement of intent on environmental taxation. To reduce demand for aggregate and encourage the use of alternative materials where possible.

Are there any exemptions?

The following materials are exempt or not within the scope of the levy; coal, lignite, shale, slate, clay, soil or vegetable or other organic matter, industrial minerals (eg metal ores, gypsum, fluorspar) and their processing waste, but not their extraction waste, cut building stone and dimension stone, limestone for the production of lime or cement, colliery spoil, waste from industrial combustion processes or the smelting or refining of metals, drill cuttings from oil exploration from the seabed, aggregate arising from utility trenching, highways excavation, navigational dredging and building construction and china clay and ball clay waste. Please note: the overburden from the extraction of china clay, ball clay, coal, lignite, slate, shale and any industrial minerals is taxable unless it is itself a specifically exempt material.

C: Highways and Access Matters

  1. Bramley Lane, the 'unclassified county road' that skirts around Backdale Quarry has collapsed because the operator quarried too close to the road. Why has the Highways Authority apparently ignored this and allowed a diversion of 'the Queen's Highway'? It is a serious criminal matter to damage a public highway in this way, but there seems to be no sanction on either the operator or the landowner.
  2. Similarly, there used to be several public rights of way through what is now a limestone quarry. Initially these were subject to temporary diversion orders, but these have now lapsed. What is the current status, and what is the plan to re-open them?
  3. The road traffic nuisance from heavy lorries is increasing all the time - not to mention the noise, dirt and accident hazard, as well as the increased damage to the carriageways.
  4. New Bridge at Calver is a 250 year-old 'listed building'.
    • Has a risk assessment on the safe working load of the bridge been carried out?
    • What happens when four 43 tonne lorries get stuck on it?
    • What is its expected life now that it is carrying loads significantly beyond what was anticipated when it was built?
    • What contingency plans are there in the event of a catastrophic failure/accident?

D: Health & Safety Matters

  • Numerous observations (with photographic evidence) of quarry operatives working without hard hats
  • The fencing around Backdale is completely inadequate for such a hazardous site. It is possible to just walk or cycle into the site from Bramley Lane - no fencing or warning signs at all. HSE claim to have dealt with this some months ago - their response is inadequate.
  • Wager's Flat will soon become seriously hazardous. There is nothing more than a dry-stone wall and a 5-bar gate to keep people out. The only hazard warning is at the gate. What will HSE do about this?

E: General Matters

We can't be too prescriptive about this - you will all have your own reasons for being concerned or irritated and getting involved. Don't let that out you off from writing to relevant people/bodies about it.

 

KEY TARGETS

Jonathan Shaw - Minster for Rural affairs at DEFRA (inc national Parks)
http://www.defra.gov.uk/corporate/ministers/shaw.htm

Hilary Benn - Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural affairs
http://www.defra.gov.uk/corporate/ministers/index.htm

- what's he going to do about it???

2. Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs (HMRC)

Aggregates Levy - it's supposed to raise over £300m per year, but they can't find the money to buy-out old mineral permissions. The total amount 're-cycled' into amelioration of the impact of aggregates extraction is only ~£4.7m per year, with only 2 projects over £100,000! Click here for more details.

Two questions:

1. Why isn't the limestone from Backdale (and now, Wager's Flat) subject to Aggregates Levy of £1.60 per tonne?
2. Why can't they find the relatively small amount to protect the national park?

How else can I contact Customs Confidential?
As an alternative to our Freephone telephone number (0800 59 5000) - you can always contact us by:
Email: Customs.Confidential@hmrc.gsi.gov.uk
Freefax 0800 528 0506
Freepost Customs Confidential, Freepost SEA 939, PO Box 100,
Gravesend, Kent DA12 2BR

Alternatively, write to the registration department for the Aggregates Levy:

HM Revenue & Customs
Central Collection Unit (AL)
Alexander House
21 Victoria Avenue
Southend-on-Sea X
SS99 1AS.

Tel: 01702 366558
Fax: 01702 366562

The Board of HMRC - should be made aware of what is (not) going on:

http://www.hmrc.gov.uk/board/index.htm

3. Derbyshire County Council - Highways Department
http://www.derbyshire.gov.uk/contact_us/

Regarding their lack of action over

  1. illegal damage to and diversion of a Public Highway, Bramley Lane
  2. permanent diversion of footpaths through Backdale Quarry

Derbyshire County Councillors: http://www.derbyshire.gov.uk/council/councillors/

4. Health & Safety Executive
http://www.hse.gov.uk/contact/index.htm

They have still not ensured adequate safety fencing around Backdale (you can walk straight in with no signs or barriers), and we don't think a 5-bar gate at Wager's Flat is adequate to stop children getting in.

5. Letters to the Peak District National Park Authority

Members of the Authority
http://www.peakdistrict.gov.uk/index/looking-after/npa/members.htm

PDNPA Managers
http://www.peakdistrict.gov.uk/index/looking-after/npa/managers.htm

6. Your local Member of Parliament

You can find your MP here and email some of them below:

Angela Smith (Sheffield Hillsborough)
Charlotte Atkins (Staffordshire Moorlands)
Kali Mountford (Colne Valley)
Michael Clapham (Barnsley West & Penistone)
Natascha Engel (North East Derbyshire)
Nicholas Clegg (Sheffield Hallam)
Patrick McLoughlin (West Derbyshire)
Phil Woolas (Oldham East & Saddleworth)
Sir Nicholas Winterton Kt (Macclesfield)
Tom Levitt (High Peak)
David Blunkett (Sheffield Brightside)
Richard Caborn (Sheffield Central)
Meg Munn (Sheffield Heeley)
Paul Holmes (Chesterfield)
Judy Mallaber (Amber Valley)
Liz Blackman (Erewash)
Janet Dean (Burton)

You can write to them at:
House of Commons
London
SW1A 0AA

and find out more about them at: http://www.epolitix.com/EN/MPWebsites
OR http://www.theyworkforyou.com/